Skip to main content Theresa's South Logo
  • Theresa's South
  • 530 Main Avenue
  • Bay Head, NJ 08742
  • (732) 892-1555
CALL US
Return to Main Menu
  • Gift Cards
  • Online Ordering
  • Christmas Eve & New Year's Eve
  • Home
  • Menus
  • Catering
  • Private Events
  • Photos
  • Directions
  • Contact Us
  • Theresa's South
  • 530 Main Avenue
  • Bay Head, NJ 08742
  • (732) 892-1555
facebook iconinstagram icon
Join Text Messenger
Receive News, Promotions & More! Join Now Resy Reservations Hours
Wednesday - Sunday
Beginning at 5:00 PM Beginning October 1st, 2026, a 3% surcharge will be added to all credit card purchases in an effort to keep our baseline prices low for everyone. This fee strictly covers rising merchant processing costs.

Holiday Menu

Christmas Eve & New Year's Eve
Three Course Prix Fixe Menu
$90 Per Person (plus tax and gratuity)

  Christmas Eve (Dec 24):
Reservations open at 12:00 AM on November 22.

New Year’s Eve (Dec 31):
Reservations open at 12:00 AM on November 29.

APPETIZERS
(Choose One)

Winter Citrus & Shaved Fennel Salad
Shaved fennel, oranges, baby arugula, honey-roasted pistachios, and pomegranate arils tossed in a champagne-pomegranate vinaigrette.

Rosemary-Garlic Shrimp Over Creamy Polenta Seared shrimp in rosemary-garlic butter, served over creamy Parmesan polenta with roasted cherry tomatoes, lemon zest, and a touch of Calabrian Chile oil for warmth.

Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
A golden-brown crab cake on a bed of baby greens, served with sweet corn salsa and spicy Cajun aioli.

Mini Calzone Fritti
Crispy Italian-style calzones filled with tomato
and melted mozzarella, served over a bed of baby greens, pesto oil, sun-dried tomato sauce for dipping.

New England Clam Chowder
Classic chowder with croutons and a hint of chili oil.

SECOND PIATTI
(Choose One)

Pan-Seared Sea Scallops
Creamy garlic smashed potatoes, sautéed baby spinach, white truffle-garlic cream sauce, topped with a sweet corn salsa

Pan-Roasted Chicken Marsala
Pan-roasted chicken breast, crisp potato croquette and grilled asparagus, smothered in a rich, sweet marsala wine and wild mushroom reduction.

Braised Lamb
Tender braised lamb over a wild mushroom and caramelized onion risotto with baby spinach, finished with rich red wine gravy and shaved black truffle Pecorino cheese

Pecan-And-Herb Crusted Salmon
Oven-roasted salmon served
atop creamy butternut squash polenta, grilled asparagus. finished with a brown butter-sage oil.

Steak Au Poivre
8 oz. New York strip with a creamy garlic smashed potatoes, sautéed spinach and brandy-peppercorn cream sauce.

Second Piatti
option house-made pasta

Gemelli With Sweet Fennel Sausage
Edna's Favorite. Gemelli Paired with Savory Sweet Fennel Sausage and Sun-Dried Tomatoes. All Tossed in a Light Tomato Cream Sauce. Finished with Parmesan

Tagliatelle With Wild Mushrooms
House-Made Tagliatelle Tossed with Shallots and Exotic Mushrooms in a Wild Mushroom-Shallot Cream Sauce. Finished with White Truffle Oil and Parmesan.

Grandma Bassi's Rigatoni Bolognese
Rigatoni Smothered in a Creamy Bolognese Sauce with Green Peas. Finished with Parmesan

Penne A La Vodka
Penne Tossed in a Pancetta Infused Creamy Tomato Sauce with Green Peas. Finished with Parmesan

Linguini Fra Diavolo
Linguini Paired with Clams, Mussels, Calamari and Shrimp. All Tossed with Garlic and Oil in a Spicy Tomato Fra Diavolo Sauce. Topped with Parmesan.
Menu Subject to change without notice

DESSERT
(Choose One)

Tiramisu
Cannoli Cake

A 3% Surcharge Will Be Added To All Credit Card Purchases
This Fee Strictly Covers Rising Merchant
Processing Costs.

Please note, we are not a certified allergen-free establishment as our kitchen handles dairy, wheat, gluten, tree nuts and peanuts. We prepare all items in a shared kitchen environment and cannot guarantee that any menu item is completely free of allergens. Inform your server of any dietary restrictions before ordering.

Items and pricing subject to change without notice.
This notice is provided for Website Accessibility best practices
You are leaving theresassouth.com
We are redirecting you to...
Website accessibility, security and privacy policies may be different than ours.
Close Notice Continue to Website
HelpAccessibility StatementPrivacy PolicyWeb Design © Restaurant Passion, Inc.